Looking for the best pizza in St. Pete? We’ve got you covered. Dive into our curated list of the top spots where you can find the most delicious and unique pizza offerings in St. Petersburg, FL. From classic New York-style to creative and experimental flavors, these pizzerias have something for everyone. Read on to discover your next favorite pizza place.
Key Takeaways
Killer Pizza is a local favorite known for classic New York-style and unique pizzas like Honey Hellfire, with a promo for free delivery.
Violet Stone offers experimental flavors with high-quality ingredients, including house-made mozzarella and wood-fired pizzas.
Jay Luigi stands out for its versatile menu and wild yeast dough, providing a unique flavor profile and variety of toppings.
🔥 ✍️ Killer Pizza: The Slice That Outsells the Chains
If you just searched “best pizza near me”, congrats — you found it. Welcome to Killer Pizza, the highest-rated, most talked-about slice in North St. Pete. We’re tucked right between Fossil Park and Riviera Bay, slinging New York-style pies that are bold, crispy, and cooked with zero compromise.
You won’t find powdered dough or mystery sauce here. We make our pizza dough fresh daily, season our tomato sauce by hand, and finish every pie with real-deal house made mozzarella, not that fake chain-store junk.
🍕 Our Top 3 Killers:
Honey Hellfire
Sweet, spicy, and straight-up evil. Loaded with pepperoni, Genoa salami, fresh garlic, and finished with a sticky-hot drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey.Meat Massacre
Not for the faint of heart. Sausage, meatballs, bacon, and Italian sausage stacked on a thin crust that fights back.Death by Goat
Goat cheese, fresh basil, cherry wood bacon, and a flavor combo that’ll haunt your tastebuds—in a good way.
🚗 Delivery That Doesn’t Rob You
Live in 33702? In Meadowlawn, Gandy, or anywhere near Fossil Park?
We deliver to your door — hot, fast, and 20% cheaper than Uber or DoorDash.
Order direct from killerpizzafla.com and use promo code FREE DELIVERY to skip the fees and stick it to the apps.
“This place is my go-to in Riviera Bay. Way better than the big names and always on time.”
— Verified Google Review, April 2025
👊 Why Locals Love Killer
After 20+ years in the pizza game, we opened Killer Pizza to serve real, crispy NY slices to a city drowning in soggy dough and up-charged apps.
Now? We’re ranked top 5 in St. Petersburg and growing faster than a pie in a 600° oven.
Come see why North St. Pete locals won’t shut up about us.
Whether you dine in, take out, or get it dropped at your door — Killer Pizza hits different.
Violet Stone: Experimental Flavors
For those who crave something a bit more adventurous, Violet Stone is the place to be. This pizzeria, which opened its brick-and-mortar location in February 2023, has quickly gained a reputation for its experimental flavors and unique approach to pizza making. Their pizzas are not exactly New York style but feature a somewhat Neapolitan-like dough that sets them apart.
One of the highlights of Violet Stone is their use of house-made mozzarella, which adds a fresh and creamy texture to their pizzas. Key features include:
Dough made with high hydration techniques, resulting in a light and airy crust
Innovative toppings that pair perfectly with the crust
Baking pizzas in a wood-fired oven, enhancing flavor with a distinct smoky taste
If you’re looking to try something new and exciting, Violet Stone’s experimental flavors and high-quality ingredients make it a must-visit spot in St. Pete. From their unique dough to their house-made mozzarella, every element of their pizzas is crafted with care and creativity.
Jay Luigi: Versatile Pizza Options
Jay Luigi is another gem in St. Pete’s pizza scene, known for its versatile pizza options that cater to a variety of tastes. Whether you’re in the mood for:
house-made sausage
soppressata
Ezzo pepperoni
italian sausage
Jay Luigi has got you covered. Their pizzas are crafted with a dough that rises using wild yeast, giving it a unique flavor and texture that’s hard to beat.
What sets Jay Luigi apart is their commitment to quality and variety:
Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients and thoughtfully selected toppings, ensuring a delicious experience with every bite.
The use of wild yeast in their dough enhances the flavor.
The wild yeast also contributes to a light and airy crust that’s perfect for any pizza lover.
If you’re looking for a pizzeria that offers a wide range of options without compromising on quality, Jay Luigi is the place to go. Their versatile menu and unique dough make for a memorable pizza experience that will keep you coming back for more.
Noble Crust: Italian-Southern Fusion
Noble Crust brings a unique twist to the pizza scene in St. Pete with its Italian-Southern fusion cuisine, including nello’s southern italian cuisine. This restaurant has quickly gained popularity since opening in January, offering a menu that combines the best of both worlds. One of the standout features of Noble Crust’s menu is their pizzas with eggs, showcasing innovative toppings that you won’t find anywhere else.
The restaurant prides itself on using locally grown, seasonal ingredients, including onions, fresh basil, and fresh mushrooms, to enhance the flavors of their recipes that have been eaten. This commitment to freshness is evident in their cold gluten free seasonal pizzas that change monthly, ensuring that there’s always something new and exciting to try at various locations, including their food truck, where you can watch the cook prepare your food.
The communal dining style promoted by Noble Crust encourages sharing plates and pizzas, making it a great spot for gatherings with friends and family. With its unique fusion of Italian and Southern cuisine, Noble Crust offers a dining experience that’s both familiar and exciting. The use of fresh, seasonal ingredients and innovative toppings make it a must-visit for anyone looking to try something new in St. Pete.
Fabrica Pizza: Hand-Stretched Neapolitan Pies
Fabrica Pizza has earned its place among the top pizza spots in the U.S., ranked 15th best overall. Specializing in hand-stretched Neapolitan pizzas, this pizzeria offers a truly authentic experience. One of their popular offerings is the Friendly Fella pizza, which features:
goat cheese
cremini mushrooms
pesto
garlic
fresh mozzarella.
The hand-stretched dough at Fabrica Pizza is a testament to their commitment to quality and tradition. Each pizza is crafted with care, resulting in a perfect balance of flavors and textures. The use of high-quality ingredients further enhances the overall dining experience, making Fabrica Pizza a standout choice for pizza lovers.
If you’re in the mood for a Neapolitan-style pizza that’s both authentic and delicious, Fabrica Pizza is the place to go. Their hand-stretched pies and carefully selected toppings make for a truly memorable meal.
Madison Avenue Pizza: Giant New York-Style Slices
Madison Avenue Pizza is the go-to spot for anyone craving a giant slice of New York-style pizza. Known for their massive 32-inch pizzas, this pizzeria takes the concept of a large slice to a whole new level. Their Angry Margherita and Angry Pepperoni pizzas are particularly popular, featuring hot peppers and Calabrian chili oil for a spicy kick.
The thin crust and generous toppings make Madison Avenue Pizza a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or sharing with friends, their giant slices topped are sure to satisfy any pizza craving at Michael’s pizzeria.
If you’re looking for a unique pizza experience that goes big on flavor and size, central avenue Madison Avenue Pizza is a must-visit. Their giant New York-style slices and spicy toppings make for a memorable dining experience.
Gianni’s NY Pizza: Thick-Crust Delights
For those who prefer a thicker crust, Gianni’s NY Pizza is the place to be. Specializing in thick-crust New York-style pizzas, Gianni’s offers a hearty and satisfying slice that will leave you craving more. Their garlic knots are also a must-try, known for their intense garlicky flavor that pairs perfectly with any pizza.
What sets Gianni’s apart is their creative topping combinations that enhance the traditional flavors of New York-style pizza. Each slice is made with care and attention to detail, ensuring a delicious experience with every bite.
If you’re a fan of thick-crust pizza, Gianni’s NY Pizza is a must-visit. Their hearty slices and delicious garlic knots make for a truly satisfying meal.
Pizza Box: Traditional Wood-Fired Pizzas
Pizza Box is known for its traditional wood-fired pizzas, offering a unique and flavorful dining experience. The ovens at Pizza Box are fueled by oak and cherry wood, which adds a distinct smoky taste to their pizzas. The dough, made from a century-old sourdough starter, creates a rich and complex flavor profile that’s hard to beat.
The high hydration technique used in their pizza dough results in a light and airy crust, making each bite a delight. Pizza Box also prides itself on using fresh dough and sauces that are prepared in-house, ensuring a high-quality pizza every time.
If you’re looking for the best pizza, a traditional wood-fired pizza that stands out in flavor and quality, Pizza Box is the place to go. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods makes for an unforgettable pizza experience.
Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen: Late-Night Favorite
Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen is a beloved late-night spot in St. Pete, staying open until 3 a.m. daily. Specializing in classic New York-style pizzas, Joey Brooklyn’s offers a variety of options that are perfect for satisfying those late-night cravings.
Popular choices include their classic cheese and pepperoni pizzas, which are a hit among late-night customers. If you find yourself hungry in the wee hours of the night, Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen is the place to be.
Cappy’s Pizzeria: Nostalgic Charm
Cappy’s Pizzeria offers a nostalgic charm that sets it apart from other pizza joints in St. Pete Beach. Key features include:
Vibrant décor
Unique self-serve beer experience, creating a fun and memorable dining atmosphere
A menu featuring both East Coast and Midwest varieties, including thin New York-style and thick Chicago-style pizzas.
The New York-style pizza at Cappy’s is thin and chewy with a sweet tomato sauce, while the Chicago-style is a deep-dish delight with a thick crust dusted with cornmeal and a spicier tomato sauce. This variety ensures that there’s something for everyone, regardless of their pizza preference.
If you’re looking for a place with great pizza and a nostalgic vibe, Cappy’s Pizzeria is a must-visit. Their diverse menu and unique dining experience make it a standout spot in St. Pete.
Summary
St. Pete is truly a pizza lover’s paradise, offering a wide range of options that cater to every taste and preference. From the classic New York-style slices at Killer Pizza and Joey Brooklyn’s to the innovative Neapolitan pies at Violet Stone and Fabrica Pizza, there’s something for everyone in this vibrant city.
Whether you’re craving a giant slice from Madison Avenue Pizza or a thick-crust delight from Gianni’s, the variety and quality of pizzas in St. Pete are sure to impress. So, what are you waiting for? Grab a friend, head out to one of these amazing pizza spots, and discover your new favorite slice!
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Killer Pizza a local favorite in St. Pete?
Killer Pizza is a local favorite because of its awesome New York-style pizzas and quirky menu options like the Honey Hellfire and Death by Goat. Plus, they have discounts and free delivery, making it a go-to spot for great food!
What is unique about Violet Stone’s pizzas?
Violet Stone’s pizzas are special because they use a Neapolitan-like dough, house-made mozzarella, and are cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving them a distinct and delicious flavor.
What type of pizza does Jay Luigi specialize in?
Jay Luigi specializes in pizzas featuring house-made sausage, soppressata, and Ezzo pepperoni, all made with unique wild yeast dough for a standout flavor.
What sets Noble Crust apart from other pizza joints?
Noble Crust stands out with its tasty mix of Italian and Southern flavors, plus they use fresh, local ingredients. Their unique pizzas and communal dining vibe make it a fun spot to enjoy a meal!
Why is Pizza Box known for its traditional wood-fired pizzas?
Pizza Box is famous for its traditional wood-fired pizzas because they use oak and cherry wood in their ovens along with a century-old sourdough starter for the dough, creating a delicious and authentic taste. Fresh, in-house prepared ingredients just add to the quality!
